What Is Email Segmentation? (+ Tips for Success)

Key Takeaways

• What is email segmentation? Dividing an email list into targeted groups based on data (like behaviors and demographics) allows brands to deliver relevant, personalized content, boosting engagement and click-through rates.
• Key segmentation strategies: Use various segmentation types — like demographic, behavioral, engagement-based, life cycle stage, and psychographic segmentation — to tailor messaging to unique subscriber needs and behaviors for higher impact.
• Quick wins for success: Prioritize A/B testing, advanced personalization, automation, and mobile optimization to enhance segmentation effectiveness, ensuring each email resonates with its intended audience.

If you’re looking to up your email game, the magic word you need is segmentation. Long gone are the days of blasting the same email to everyone on a list and hope that someone, anyone, will actually read it.  

Email marketing segmentation — essentially dividing your email list into targeted, specific groups — is the MVP of any high-impact email strategy.  

Why?  

Because it lets you deliver the right message to the right person at the right time, every time.  

Ready to get your emails noticed, clicked, and loved? Let’s dive into what email segmentation actually is, why it works, and the best strategies to get started. 

— 

Want to write emails your audience will actually respond to? 

GET YOUR FREE EMAIL MARKETING GUIDE

— 

Email segmentation means breaking up your email list into smaller, more defined groups based on data and behaviors. The goal? Deliver more relevant content to each group.  

Imagine you’re running a fitness brand. You’ve got everything from yoga mats to pre-workout powders. Do your subscribers who bought yoga gear care about your new line of protein shakes? Maybe. But people who’ve shown an interest in nutrition products are definitely more likely to click. 

By segmenting, you can send tailored messages that speak to each subscriber’s unique interests and needs. And the stats back it up: Segmented email campaigns have a whopping 100.95% higher click-through rate than non-segmented ones.  

Let’s unpack some of the best segmentation strategies to elevate your email marketing. 

1. Demographic segmentation: This classic approach is where most people start. Use data points like age, gender, location, and job title to tailor your messaging.
   • Example: Suppose you’re an online beauty retailer. While the 20-something crowd and older consumers both value skincare, their needs and wants are vastly different. Segmenting based on age would allow you to tailor your emails to suggest highly relevant products and skincare advice.
   • Pro tip: Go beyond age and gender. Think lifestyle and social responsibility. For example, Gen Z values transparency, ethics, and brands that align with their personal values. Tailor those messages accordingly. 

2. Behavioral segmentation: Behavioral segmentation is the ultimate way to meet your customers where they are. This means looking at things like browsing behavior, purchase history, and engagement with past emails.
   • Example: For those who’ve clicked on a blog post about winter fashion but haven’t purchased anything, a fashion brand could send a curated selection of winter staples along with a first-purchase discount incentive. For loyal buyers, you could skip the discount and push the exclusivity angle.
   • Pro tip: Leverage AI tools to automate and refine these segments. Tools like HubSpot can predict which types of products or content a subscriber might be interested in based on past behaviors, saving you time and guesswork. 

3. Engagement-based segmentation: Segmentation based on engagement level is your way of tailoring content to fans, followers, and the MIA crew alike. Break down your list into “active,” “inactive,” and “lapsed” subscribers.
   • Example: For highly engaged users who click on most emails, send VIP-only sales and sneak peeks. For the “lapsed” folks? Reengagement campaigns featuring bold subject lines, personalized offers, and a bit of FOMO can help lure them back.
   • Pro tip: Pay attention to “list hygiene.” Delete or reduce sends to those who aren’t engaging at all after a few tries. It’s good for your sender reputation and can improve your open rates.  

4. Life cycle stage segmentation: Where a customer sits in the buyer’s journey matters more than ever. Are they a first-time subscriber? Loyal customer? Ready-to-buy lead? Personalize accordingly.
   • Example: For new subscribers, a welcome series introducing your brand and its values is key. For loyal customers, consider a thank-you series with behind-the-scenes stories or early access to new products.
   • Pro tip: The buyer’s journey isn’t always linear, and life cycle segmentation can feel a bit like a moving target. Use real-time data to track changes in your customers’ engagement and adapt your messaging with dynamic content accordingly.  

5. Psychographic segmentation: Psychographics dig into the “why” behind the purchase — values, interests, and lifestyle, for example.
   • Example: If your apparel brand focuses on sustainability, segment the subscribers who’ve shown an interest in eco-friendly content and products. Speak to their values with content about your ethical production processes or sustainable materials.
   • Pro tip: Use surveys, quizzes, or even zero-party data from social platforms to gather psychographic data directly from customers. Then, tailor your messaging to these deeper, more meaningful connections. 

• Leverage A/B testing for segments. Test different subject lines, send times, and calls to action within each segment to discover what works best. You’d be surprised how much a simple tweak can improve engagement.

• Personalize, personalize, personalize. “Hi [First Name]” isn’t enough anymore. Use details like location (“Hey, Los Angeles! Here’s what’s trending in your area.”), past purchases, or even favorite categories to create that “wow, this brand gets me” moment.

• Automate. Automation lets you keep up with segmentation without burning out. Set up triggers for welcome sequences, cart abandonment, post-purchase follow-ups, and reengagement emails. Let’s face it — no one has time to manually segment emails anymore.

• Optimize for mobile. With over 55% of emails opened on mobile devices, make sure your emails look good and load quickly on phones and tablets.  

Email segmentation is evolving fast, and if you’re serious about staying competitive, it’s time to go beyond basic demographic breakdowns. The email MVPs will be the brands that experiment with creative, highly personalized segmentation strategies that respect subscribers’ interests, values, and behaviors. 

So here’s your homework: Dive into your email data and start breaking it down by what truly matters to your audience. By understanding your subscribers and delivering content that resonates, you’ll be on track to make this your best email marketing year yet.